Citing to the Blogosphere

| 1 Comment

The newest (18th) edition of the Bluebook features a new rule for citing to blog posts:

Posting to blogs take one of two formats. If there is only one poster to the blog, cite as a Web page, but include the date and time-stamp to indicate the specific posting cited. If there are multiple posters on the blog, cite as a posting to a discussion forum. In both cases, indicate the title of the blog before the URL:
single poster - How Appealing, (Sept. 1, 2004, 21:20 EST).

multiple posters - Posting of Lyle Denniston to SCOTUSblog, (Sept. 28, 2004, 13:26 EST).

Instead of taking advantage of permalinks and post titles, this citation format makes it more complicated and difficult to find a cited resource.

Anthony Rickey notes that the Yale Law Journal's new website, The Pocket Part, suggests that authors disregard the Bluebook suggested form for citing to blogs and use a citation format that makes sense: Bluebook Followup: Do As We Say, Not As We Do: "Nice to see one of the Gang of Four deciding that the rules on blog citation don't make sense."

One argument (made in a comment to Rickey) is that the Pocket Part is a "web site," not a "blog." Why are the rules for citation different? How are authors supposed to to evaluate whether an internet resource is a "web site" or a "blog?"

The Bluebook rule actually makes some amount of sense for an internet resource that has no more precise way to point to a specific page. But why not cite the author's name in a single author blog? What is to be done with blogs that use only category-based archiving, rather than date-based archiving?

1 Comment

Or for that matter, what is to be done with blogs that are anonymous, don't reveal their location, and don't publish a time zone on their page or in their RSS feed?


A work in progress

Recent Entries

This is a test entry. Feel free to not get excited.…
Once More With Feeling -- Fox v. FCC back at SCOTUS
We've been here before, but now the Supreme Court is again hearing arguments on the FCC's indecency standards, in particular…
On Thursday morning, the House Judiciary Committee will have a full committee markup of the latest version of H.R. 3261…